Wrap-Up of the 2021 Cruisin' Through the Cozies Challenge

I signed up to read 10 books for this challenge.  I met the challenge with 18 books! Here they are:

The Hawaiian Discovery by Wanda Brunstetter

Plaid and Plagiarism by Molly MacRae

Haunted Hibiscus by Laura Childs

The French Paradox by Ellen Crosby

Followed by Helen Macie Oysterman

Killer Deadline by Lauren Carr

The Blended Quilt by Wanda Brunstetter

Persian Perpetrator by Katherine Hay-don

Peaches and Schemes by Anna Gerard

The Amish Quilter's Unexpected Baby by Jennifer Beckstrand

Return to the Big Valley by Wanda Brunstetter

Ice Blue by Emma Jameson

Loch Down Abbey by  Beth Cowan-Erskine

Hemlock by Susan Wittig Albert

Twisted Tea Christmas by Laura Childs

The Beginning by Beverly Lewis

Turkey Trot Murder by Leslie Meier

A Lancaster Family Christmas by Kate Lloyd

Favorite Book:  Hemlock

Second Favorite Book:  Twisted Tea Christmas 

Least Favorite Book:  Plaid and Plagiarism

7 of the authors were new to me. It's interesting that 5 of the books are Amish fiction and that 3 of them were written by Wanda Brustetter. I didn't start out expecting to read Amish fiction but it worked out that way.  I have lost some of my enthusiasm for cozies but still read favorite authors Susan Wittig Albert, Laura Childs, Cleo Coyle and Ellen Crosby.  I began reading some new authors but couldn't become interested in them and gave up. I have always enjoyed Amish fiction and, frankly, could not complete the challenge without them.

A Lancaster Family Christmas

A Lancaster Family Christmas is a feel good holiday story about a Mennonite family and a city girl. Diana Manzella agrees to take an out of town trip with co-worker Betsy Yoder to visit the Yoder family in Lancaster County. Diana is an only child who comes from a family with distant parents.  She muses that her parents do not even know what subject she majored in during college. When Diana arrives in Amish Country she discovers that their world is completely different from her own on the Upper East Side of New York City. She isn't sure that she can make it through the weekend. However, Diana is fascinated by the huge homes and buggies but takes note that these families get along and have huge home cooked meals every day. This, too, is vastly different from her parent's household.  Diana also notices Betsy's brother Brett and his Amish friend Jesse.  She is attracted to both of them even though she knows nothing can come of a relationship with either of them because of their religious faith.

The food alone that Betsy's mother cooks will get you in the holiday spirit. It is hard to believe that there are women in the world who spend that much time in the kitchen. They seem to have limitless energy.  A Lancaster Family Christmas is a good book to start the holiday season with.  I am rating it 5 out of 5 stars.

Turkey Trot Murder

The Turkey Trot Murder takes place in Tinker's Cove, Maine where the our protagonist, Lucy Stone lives. Lucy expects that the upcoming Thanksgiving holiday will be uneventful. However, while training for the annual turkey trot 5K Lucy sees a dead body frozen in Blueberry Pond. Alison Franklin, daughter of the wealthy Ed Franklin, struggled with opioid addiction after an injury a year prior. The police blame her death on an accidental overdose but Lucy, a reporter for the local paper, disagrees. Alison had it all, wealth, looks and education. While covering the funeral for the paper, Lucy is puzzled to see Ed Franklin bring his new, young and pregnant wife Mireille with him. Alison's mother, Eudora Clare, arrives at the funeral with her new husband covered in black gauze to outshine Mireille. As the residents of Tinker's Cove become uneasy over the third drug death in a year, Lucy investigates Alison's death for her paper. Soon, a new family moves into town to reopen a restaurant. The Rodriguezes are Hispanic and are opposed by the community who blames Mexicans for the drug epidemic.  Ed Franklin is the most vocal of them. 

I thoroughly enjoyed the book but readers who are tired of hearing about the national divide over immigration will want to skip it. The author takes a Democratic point of view on immigration. There is much more to the story though. The mystery over Alison's death deepens when another resident is killed. We also have several opposing parties in the story.  Mireille versus Eudora, Ed versus Rey Rodgriguez and Lucy's daughter Zoe versus Matt Rodriguez. You don't know which of them will prevail. Turkey Trot Murder is the 24th Lucy Stone Mystery but I have only read 2 of them previously.  I thought that these cozies were too traditional for my taste but Turkey Trot has an intricate plot with tight writing.   I highly recommend it.

5 out of 5 stars.

Twisted Tea Christmas

The Twisted Tea Christmas is the 23rd installment of the Indigo Teashop Mystery series by Laura Childs.  While I have heavily criticized her writing in the past 5 years, this novel puts her back on track. It is fantastic. I always love it when the murder occurs quickly so that the rest of the book can be about the solving of the murder.  Here, we have a murder on the 5th page and is is not resolved until the second to last page.  The publisher's summary is below:

Tea maven Theodosia Browning and her tea sommelier, Drayton Connelley, are catering a Victorian Christmas party at a swanky mansion in downtown Charleston for Drucilla Hayward, one of the wealthiest women in town. As the champagne flows and the tea steeps, Drucilla is so pleased with the success of her soiree that she reveals her secret plan to Theodosia.  The grande dame has brought the cream of Charleston society together to reveal that she is planning to give her wealth away to various charitable organizations. However, before she can make the announcement, Theodosia finds her crumpled unconscious in the hallway. It looks like the excitement has gotten to the elderly women, but it may have been helped along by the syringe in her neck.  

I am happy that there were no cheesy statements like "the phone rang ding-a-ling-ring" and that secondary character Delaine Dish's emotions were under control.  The main change that I liked is that the murder did not occur in the same place as it did in the prior 22 books.  It was time for a change and we now have a perfectly plotted and written cozy mystery to enjoy.  There was something else new that tickled my fancy. One evening when Theodosia went to bed with a book, it was a  book written by Susan Wittig Albert!  Albert writes the China Bayles cozy mystery series. I have to wonder if Childs and Albert are friends.

The Charleston setting was a good choice to place the series in.  It has marvelous architecture, fairly nice weather and history galore.  It gives the writer alot to work with when creating atmosphere. The main characters are Theodosia, Drayton and police investigator Burt Tidwell.  These characters have grown over the years but in Twisted Tea Christmas they do not have growth, they just work together to solve the murder. I loved this as I am mainly a whodunnit fan. Author Childs gives us plenty of red herrings, more than we usually have in her books. It made the novel suspenseful.  In fact, I had a hard time figuring out who committed the murder and was surprised at the ending.  

I am proud to give this book a rating of 5 out of 5 stars. Ya'll need to read this one.

The Beginning

It has always amazed me how Beverly Lewis can continue to come up with great stories to tell.  41 adult fiction novels has not slowed down her imagination. The Beginning is another one that is especially poignant. While her readers will expect a romance story that always ends well, the reason for the title has nothing to do with courting and marriage. I won't be a spoiler. You will want to read the book to find out.

The story begins with Susie Mast wondering if she will ever have any boy interested enough in her to want to marry her. She hopes that Obie Yoder has romantic feelings for her but she never expresses her feelings to him.  Suffering from the death of her brother several years earlier, Susie has found that the best way to cope is to keep busy. She is always cleaning, working in her mother's store or selling her family tree embroideries. She rarely relaxes or socializes. Susie's mother, Aquilla, has been in declining health since the death of her husband and son in an auto accident. Her adopted sister, Britta, is a big help to her with chores but has begun to ask alot of questions about her birth parents. Susie knows a little about Britta's past but is afraid to tell her anything about her adoption.  She fears more loss will occur if Britta gets the answers she is seeking.  

The Beginning is one of my favorite books that Lewis has written. The ending gathers and clarifies all the loose ends written in to the story.  While I haven't read all of her books, this type of ending seemed more complex than the ones that I have previously read.  It made the book much more satisfying than the usual girl finally gets the boy.  The wisdom issued from the lips of the elderly women in this Amish district was amazing and the foods the ladies prepared made me hungry.  I ended up ordering in on the day that I read the book.  If there is anything unusual about the story  it was how often they made tea. Someone was making tea on almost every page. The characters must have spent alot of time in the outhouse.

Beverly Lewis is the reason that I read Amish fiction.  She is the gold standard for these types of stories and I highly recommend this novel.  5 out of 5 stars.

Hemlock

Hemlock's action takes place far away from its usual Pecan Springs, Texas location. For most authors this results in a poorly written novel. In fact, Susan Wittig Albert did this once before and the book was awful. In Hemlock, though, she has masterfully written a story that is engaging from the first page until the last.

Our main character China Bayles receives a phone call from a friend in North Carolina. She is asked by Dorothea Harper, director of the Hemlock House Foundation, to visit her to help her with locating a missing, rare book titled A Curious Herbal. The book was written by Elizabeth Blackwell in the fifteenth century and contains her drawings of 500 herbs and plants that apothecaries used to treat people. The book vanished from its locked display case in Hemlock House, an old mansion in the North Carolina mountains. 

Another prominent character is Jenna Peterson, a graduate student who is interning at Hemlock House and is assisting Dorothea with cataloging the thousands of books in the library. Both Jenna and Dorothea live in the mansion. The police believe that one of them stole the book, mainly because they are the only people with access to the library. It's value is in the hundreds of thousands and would make either one of them wealthy. Additional characters include Police Chief Curtis, bookseller Jed Conway,  and Elizabeth Blackwell herself.  Elizabeth's story is told via drafts of a historical novel that Jenna is writing and sends to China for input. Elizabeth's story is a big part of Hemlock and is the most interesting part of the novel. There are several minor characters who are not mentioned often but are integral to solving the mystery.  These include relatives, the housekeeper and members of the Hemlock House board of directors.

Hemlock is not a cozy murder mystery but rather a cozy art theft mystery. All of the prior books in the series involved the solving of a murder. This installment of the series is fantastic. There is even a little suspense. When China walks up the rickety stairs of the mansion it is implied that she is avoiding danger of some sort not related to the steps.  This is a red herring. There are quite a few of these types of hints in the book and you don't know what will be important until the end of the story.

Hemlock is one of the author's best novels. 5 out of 5 stars.

Loch Down Abbey

Loch Down Abbey is a Downton Abbey wannabe. Fortunately for the author, it will be made in to a TV series. As a book, there wasn't much of a plot. 2 characters died but the resolution of their deaths was not prominent. The story was basically about how the aristocratic characters spend their days. The story takes place in the Scottish Highlands during the 1930s.

The publisher's summary:

"It's the 1930s and a mysterious illness is spreading over Scotland. But the noble and ancient family of Inverkillen, residents of Loch Down Abbey, are much more concerned with dwindling toilet roll supplies and who will look after the children now that Nanny has regretfully (and most inconveniently) departed this life.

Then Lord Inverkillen, Earl and head of the family, is found dead in mysterious circumstances. The inspector declares it an accident but Mrs MacBain, the head housekeeper, isn't so convinced. As no one is allowed in or out because of the illness, the residents of the house - both upstairs and downstairs - are the only suspects. With the Earl's own family too busy doing what can only be described as nothing, she decides to do some digging - in between chores, of course - and in doing so uncovers a whole host of long-hidden secrets, lies and betrayals that will alter the dynamics of the household for ever." 

Loch Down Abbey is advertised as a locked room mystery. Who or what was in the locked room? I don't know. The book primarily revolves around an artistocratic family, the Ogilvy-Sinclairs, who have lived in Loch Down Abbey for over 600 years. They are dysfunctional, with every family member at war with each other over mostly small things. They love to make life hard for their servants and treat them abysmally. After Lord Inverkillen and the nanny are found dead, a sickness takes over Scotland and Britain. The government has asked people to wear masks and stay inside while the sickness rages. In the Abbey, half of the servants are ill and cannot wait on the  family hand and foot. The family is outraged that servants have taken over part of the family and guest quarters and that they will have to dress themselves, forego their breakfast trays and downsize the number of cakes served at tea. Flour, sugar and toilet paper have been hoarded from the stores. Sound familiar? I think the author wrote her story based on the COVID-19 pandemic that we all are dealing with at the present time. 

The depiction of the lives of the rich are what make this a good read. I am sure that we all have watched Downton Abbey over the years. Loch Down Abbey is a castle that is slightly smaller in size than Downton but the characters all behave the same. Loch Down has more servants though, thirty, so there are alot of characters to keep track of. There isn't much mystery here but it did not affect my enjoyment of the book. It is a relaxing read.

4 out of 5 stars.

Ice Blue

Ice Blue is the first book in Emma Jameson's Lord & Lady Hetheridge Mystery Series. The series takes place in Britain during the present era. I loved the book as it follows the police procedural formula perfectly, making it an easy read.

The publisher's summary:

"Anthony Hetheridge, ninth Baron of Wellegrave, Chief Superintendent for New Scotland Yard, never married, no children, no pets, no hobbies and not even an interesting vice, will turn sixty in three weeks. With the exception of his chosen career, too sordid for his blue-blooded family to condone, his life has been safe and predictable. But then he mets Detective Sergeant Kate Wakefield-beautiful, willful, and nearly half his age. When Hetheridge saves the outspoken, impetuous young detective from getting the sack, siding with her against Scotland Yard's powerful male hierarchy, his cold, elegant balanced world spins out of control. Summoned to London's fashionable Belgravia to investigate the brutal murder of a financier, Hetheridge must catch the killer while coping with his growing attraction to Kate, the reappearance of an old flame, and the secret that emerges from his own past."

In the past I have said that I liked many of the books that I have reviewed on this blog. For most of them, I do not read anything else by the author due to time constraints. However, I loved Ice Blue so much that I have already ordered the rest of the books in the series. This book was so well written that it was a joy to read. 

When I began the book I thought that it was a cozy mystery. It is. What confused me was the rough British slang that the Scotland Yard investigators used when referring to sex or sexual orientation. You don't usually see that in a cozy but since the book is advertised as a cozy mystery, I accept that categorization. The dialogue seemed natural, given that Kate was the only female detective in a male dominated office. In addition, the novel was so British-centric that I thought that author Emma Jameson was British. She isn't. Ms. Jameson is American but loves all things English. 

Ice Blue is a winner! I recommend it to mystery fans. 4 out of 5 stars.

Peaches and Schemes

Peaches and Schemes is the third book in the Georgia Bed and Breakfast Mysteries by Anna Gerard. This is a cozy mystery series featuring amateur sleuth Nina Fleet. The story takes place in Cymbeline, Georgia and opens with Nina taking a booth at the Veils and Vanities Bridal Expo in order to tap into the destination wedding market. This twice-yearly event is sponsored by the town's two wedding pros: Virgie Hamilton, the sixtysomething owner of Virgie's Formals, and Roxana Quarry, a Generation X event planner and Nina's new friend. Of course, everything goes wrong during the expo's fashion show when Roxana comes tumbling out of an oversized wedding cake apparently strangled to death by a scarf. Virgie is arrested for the crime after Nina gives a statement to the police about having overheard the woman accusing her partner of embezzlement. The situation becomes more tense when Nina's nemesis and tenant Harry Westcott tells Nina that her ex-husband is engaged to be married again. Believing that Virgie's only offense is her bad temper, Nina decides to begin an investigation into Roxana's murder. 

Peaches and Schemes is your traditional southern cozy and it provided a great escape for me on a lazy Saturday afternoon. While it is the third novel in the series, it is a standalone novel for those who are new to the series, such as myself. Some southern stories can be saccharine sweet but this one had so many twists and turns to taper the sweetness down a little bit. The plot was advanced on just about every page so there was some suspense too. The author wrote a little humor into her dialogue too which added to my enjoyment of the book.  The one thing that I didn't like was Nina telling others to pronounce her name as Nine-ah. I thought this was annoying and not something a southern belle should or would do. Other than that, Peaches and Schemes is the perfect cozy mystery. 

5 out of 5 stars.

Return to the Big Valley

This book shares three novellas about Amish women and their boyfriends. The stories take place in Big Valley, PA where the Brides of Big Valley novel occurred. Each story is a standalone and is written by a member of the Brunstetter family. Wanda wrote Wilma's Wish, her daughter-in-law Jean wrote Martha's Miracle and Wanda's granddaughter Richelle wrote Alma's Acceptance. Each one is about 120 pages long and are easy reads. 

In Wilma's Wish we see engaged couple Israel Zook and Wilma Hostetler struggling to care for Israel's five nephews. The boys are orphans and a little rambunctious. Israel has decided to adopt them but is not sure if Wilma will still marry him. The boys do not get along with her and are trying to discourage her from marrying Israel by behaving badly. Martha Yoder, of Martha's Wish, is an unusual Amish girl. She prefers hunting and fishing to cooking and cleaning. Her parents worry that she will never find someone to marry her if she continues in her tomboy ways. In Alma's Acceptance, Alma Wengerd is a widow after only one year of marriage. She decides to visit a friend in Big Valley where she lived when she was younger. There she reunites with a friend who she once thought of marrying  Elias also wanted to marry her but never got up the courage to ask her out. All of these stories deal with grief, romance, and those wonderful, always caring parents. 

I enjoyed Wilma's Wish and Alma's Acceptance. Martha's Wish was too simplistic and the characters were not interesting. There was no tension in the plot and I got bored reading this story. I would have to say, though, that all three stories were lacking the usual amount of tension and character development that readers are used to seeing with full length Amish fiction.  However, the book as a whole was a relaxing read and I will rate it 3 out of 5 stars.

Persian Perpetrator

When I purchased this cozy mystery for my Kindle, I thought it was a full length  novel. However, it is only 113 pages long. The story began well with the introduction of the characters, including a Persian cat named Monkey Business.  The coronavirus shutdown has just begun in Christchurch, New Zealand where the story takes place. The author's dialogue between the characters was the apparatus used to advance the plot. In a modern twist, all of the dialogue was via Zoom community meetings. I knew that one day we would be reading stories that take place during Covidtide but I didn't expect it to happen so quickly.  

Because of the shortness of the script there was no sleuthing here.  Gossip among the city residents tells the reader who killed Lilith, an elderly woman. No investigation of Lilith's murder is mentioned either. In this respect the book was a let down. I was impressed, though, at the naturalness of the conversations between neighbors as well as showing how they had a hard time adjusting to lockdown. I also expected that the series would prominently feature a feline. Monkey Business did not have a role in the plot so I am unclear what the title refers to.

There are 4 more books in this series. I can only assume that they are short like Persian Perpetrator. I think I will skip them. 1 out of 5 stars.

The Hawaiian Discovery

This is the second book in a three part series. I have already read books 1 and 3. I was not aware that these 3 novels were connected and read them out of order. It was easy to follow the story though.

On this installment of the series Ellen Lambright, an Amish girl living in Middlebury, IN, receives permission from her church to fly to Kaui in order to help a friend deal with her husband's accident. Ken Williams was attacked by a shark while surfing and might not survive. His wife Mandy, also from Middlebury, is Ellen's best friend so after the accident happened Ellen knew Mandy would need support.  When she arrives Ellen meets Rob Smith, a farm hand working on the organic farm owned by the Williams family. Sparks fly between them and both try to ignore their mutual attraction. With Ellen having joined the Amish Church she cannot marry an Englisher and it is best not to become involved with one. Both of them know this and try to resist the temptation.

I love Amish fiction and I also love Hawaii. Put the two together and you have a winning novel. I love reading about these characters and hope Brunstetter continues their story in another book. However, it is the setting that grabs my attention most. With every description of the scenery I feel as though I have been transported there.  Yes, I feel that warm sun even though I am living in a cold climate. While these characters are hard workers, I have some problems relating to their fatigue after a day's work. They have the sunshine when the day is over which gives me a disconnect. I cannot imagine feeling tired in such a glorious setting. My personal issues do not affect my enjoyment of the story. It was well written and I read it this morning before I went to work.

5 our of 5 stars.

The French Paradox

The French Paradox is the 11th wine country mystery by Ellen Crosby. The mystery here involves Jackie Onassis and Lucie Montgomery's grandfather during their time together in Paris in 1949.  Jackie was there as an exchange student from Smith College.  While she was living there Jackie purchased several inexpensive paintings by an unknown 18th century artist.  Jackie also had a romantic relationship with a Virginia vineyard owner, Lucie's grandfather, which until recently was a well kept secret.

Seventy years later, Cricket Delacroix, Lucie's neighbor and Jackie's schoolfriend, is donating the now priceless paintings to a Washington, DC museum.  Lucie's grandfather is flying in to Virginia for Cricket's 90th birthday party which is being hosted by her daughter Harriet.  Harriet is rewriting a manuscript that Jackie left behind about Marie Antoinette and her portraitist.  Harriet is also planning on adding tell all secrets about Jackie to ensure that her book is a success.  On the eve of the party a world renowned landscape designer is found dead in Lucie's vineyard. The question is whether someone killed him for his thoughts on climate change, his connection to Jackie and the paintings.  

I had a difficult time getting interested in this novel and put it down for a few weeks. When I started reading again, it was still a little off. I noticed that the reader does not know that the landscape designer's death was a murder until the 80th page. That's is a long time to wait in a 243 page cozy mystery. There were several new characters too that probably won't be in future books. I wasn't sure if I should care about them or not but they were not memorable to say the least. Several of the usual characters did not have a role.

Perhaps I am just used to the usual formula that the author uses when writing her novels and expected the same.  I had a hard time accepting that Jackie Onassis had a connection but once I did the story then changed to a murder. The alternating plots didn't gel for me but several reviewers enjoyed the book.

2 out of 5 stars.

The Blended Quilt

The Blended Quilt is Wanda Brunstetter's 56th novel.  She created the Amish fiction genre in 1997 with the publication of her first book A Merry Heart.  She was 60 years old when that book was published! Although her ancestors were of the Anabaptist faith, her fascination with the Amish began when she married her husband, who had been raised as a Mennonite.  She is so well thought of in the Amish community that they read her books.  In addition to her Amish fiction series, Ms. Brunstetter has published 8 novellas, 7 cookbooks, 3 devotionals, 4 gift books and 14 middle grade children's novels, all set among the Amish.  She publishes between 3 and 8 books per year and began writing with her daughter-in-law Jean Brunstetter in 2016.  The Robin's Greeting was published earlier this month and next month An Amish Barn Raising will be published.

The Blended Quilt follows the life of Sadie Kuhns.  A year after returning to Indiana from a trip to Hawaii (see The Hawaiian Quilt) Sadie wants to create a quilt that blends the traditional Amish quilt with a Hawaiian quilt.  When she finishes it, a friend suggests that she write a book on the quilt. While she is writing her book, her boyfriend Wyman Kauffman becomes distant as she spends more time writing and talking about it than in paying attention to him.  He is jealous of the time that she spends with her personal pursuits and wonders if she is marriage material.  However, Sadie had concerns about their relationship before she even thought about making the quilt.  Wyman does not seem to be able to a job or profession.  Without a secure profession, Sadie doubts that he can support a wife and family.  Both wonder if there is any reason to continue their courtship.  

I have only read 4 other books by Wanda Brunstetter.  I am not sure why since her books are so well written.  At one time I was only interested in political mysteries but I believe I have let myself down by not reading her entire bibliography of books.  I loved The Blended Quilt and must make a determination to read through her book list.  As a feminist I was put off by Wyman's insistence on being center stage in Sadie's life.  Perhaps that is impractical given Sadie's Amish life but he annoyed me. Sadie, however, is a woman after my own heart.  Wanting to create a new type of quilt is impressive.  Writing a book about it is even better (in my view). Being a strong woman was not looked upon well in her community. Neither was travel, something Sadie has done while single.  She would like to return to Hawaii but never expects to be able to afford it.  While I realize that this is Amish fiction, I cannot wrap my head around the fact that being strong and proactive is considered a negative trait in a woman. 

5 our of 5 stars.

Haunted Hibiscus

Haunted Hibiscus is the 22nd Indigo Tea Shop mystery by Laura Childs.  I have loved this series since it began but in the last several years the books have been hit or miss for me.  This particular installment of the series is a miss.  I think that because the author writes three different series concurrently and pushes out 3 books per year, she is getting lazy with her writing.  I will explain more fully below but here is the publisher's summary of the novel:

"It is the week before Halloween and Theodosia Browning, proprietor of the Indigo Tea Shop, and her tea sommelier, Drayton, are ghosting through the dusk of a cool Charleston evening on their way to the old Bouchard Mansion.  Known as the Grey Ghost, this dilapidated place was recently bequeathed to the Heritage Society, and tonight heralds the grand opening of their literary and historical themed haunted house.

Though Timothy Neville, the Patriarch of the Heritage Society, is not thrilled with the fund-raising idea, it is the perfect venue for his grandniece, Willow French, to sign copies of her new book, Carolina Crimes & Capers.  But amidst a parade of characters dressed as Edgar Allen Poe, Lady Macbeth, and the Headless Horseman, Willow's body is suddenly tossed from the third-floor tower room and left to dangle at the end of a rope.  Police come screaming in and Theodosia's boyfriend, Detective Pete Riley, is sent to Willow's apartment to investigate.  But minutes later, he is shot and wounded by a shadowy intruder.

Timothy begs Theodosia to investigate, and shaken by Riley's assault, she readily agrees.  Now, she questions members of the Heritage Society and a man who claims the mansion is rightfully his, as well as Willow's book publisher and fiance, all while hosting a Sherlock Holmes tea and catering several others." 

Perhaps I have become tired of this series. The exact same things happen in the exact same places in the novels. You always know what Timothy Neville's reactions will be. The Heritage Society is always about to go under.  There is no variety to the series.  While all of the prior books in the series could have been standalone novels, this one isn't.  There is no background information on the characters.  Also, Theodosia seemed quite angry throughout the story.  She is normally a sweet, polite southerner.  A few of the phrases in Haunted Hibiscus that annoyed me in include:

• the front door da-dinged
• I only have time for drive-by kisses and hugs
• He's as wide as a soccer mom's van
• Holy cats, what a mess
• Floradora Florist
• Being young and dipped in folly, I fell in love with melancholy

I think that I will check out from this series.  I doesn't do anything for me.  I am rating it 2 out of 5 stars because the plot premise was good.  It just wasn't executed well.

Killer Deadline

Lauren Carr writes stand alone cozy mysteries. I have to wonder, though, if Killer Deadline is the beginning of a series as the front cover references "a Nikki Bryant cozy mystery."  The characters are perfect for one and the main character has a job as a TV news station owner, which will give her a good reason for being an amateur sleuth.  Add in Nikki's photogenic "ugly" dog and you have the ingredients for a perfect series.

This awesome story begins with Nikki's return to Pine Grove, Pennsylvania after working as a journalist for several years in Las Vegas and Washington, D.C. With her mother's decision to retire from the news business, Nikki comes home to take over the station that her father began over thirty years ago.  Soon after her arrival Nikki finds the dead body of her news anchor Ashleigh Addison, who is also her childhood rival.  The night before her death, Ashleigh was at a party to welcome Nikki where Ashleigh stated that she would be airing live an explosive news story the next day.  The question for the police and for Nikki  is whether her news story is connected to the murder of Nikki's father in his office at the station.  

Killer Deadline was an enjoyable read. It is a modern cozy with accomplished, power hungry women. Ashleigh is the traditional female character who cares more about appearances than substance. The fact that she is the novel's victim is telling for me.  I would expect the aggressive female character to be the victim in a cozy.  I like to see this connection to the modern world. 

The plot was a straightforward murder mystery.  It moved fast with the murder of Nikki's father taking precedence over Ashleigh's murder. I love it when the mystery formula is followed faithfully. Of course, you can never go wrong by using a dog as a character. 

5 out of 5 stars!

Followed

 

I loved Helen Macie Osterman's Emma Winberry mystery series so when I found her book Followed, I knew that I had to read it. It is a cozy mystery and is a stand alone novel.

Meg Lewis feels that she is being followed. Soon she sees a blue car every night driving past her grandmother's home where Meg lives with her daughter and grandmother. Meg recognizes the driver as a man who visited a patient at the hospital where she works at as a nurse.  Taking precautions, Meg doesn't let her daughter Becky out of her sight. Meg's grandmother, Lillian Sparks, decides to get a dog and install an electric fence for added security. However, the first time they become lax in watching Becky, Becky and her dog disappear from the back yard. 

While the book follows a mystery formula, there is also some romance. Meg has begun dating a young doctor who she met at work. Curt Williams is the perfect boyfriend who also loves Meg's daughter. Grandmother Lil also has a boyfriend. Together this fivesome would make a great family, that is, if they ever get hitched. 

Followed is a traditional cozy with no sex or violence. I assumed all would end well in the plot since this is a cozy, but there was still a mystery concerning how it would happen. I devoured the book in one sitting. It was the perfect respite for a snowy afternoon.

5 out of 5 stars.

Plaid and Plagiarism

Plaid and Plagiarism was a disconnect for me.  There were too many descriptive phrases per page instead of action. For instance, Obsessive Outlanders and Born Again Braveheart were one of 10 descriptions on a page.  "Janet and Christine made comforting bookends for the young women in between them." "You didn'task Rab why he rabbited off the harborwall." " I didn't want to ask about his Nessie boxers." "Ooh, is that one of those fancy instant-hot, instant-cold, instant ooh-la-la taps?"  "Let's put the unsavory bits to bed." What the heck do these descriptions mean? I guess the book was written for a UK audience as the author has used many words that only the British use.

Also, the run-up to the murder itself made no sense.  Our two main characters were searching someone's house because it had been trashed. The body was found elsewhere, in a shed, and I did not see the connection between spending 20 pages on searching the house and one sentence on the shed. In addition, when they were peeking into the windows of the house?  Why did they call the police for an emergency when they saw a person move inside the house?  Perhaps the person lived there. Afterward they entered the house to see if more than the kitchen was trashed. Why? This was not connected to the body in the shed and there didn't seem to be any reason why they could enter this house.

What is the book supposed to be about? The publisher's blurb refers to two friends opening a bookshop and they are going to be amateur sleuths solving a murder. Nothing else is written about the plot in the blurb and I can only assume that even the publisher doesn't see any plot action. 

It seems to me that this book is all setting descriptions and no plot. Perhaps the author was trying to set some groundwork for a new cozy mystery series. However, the book was too dull for me to even consider reading any future books in the series.

2021 Cruisin' Through the Cozies Sign-Up

I did not participate in the Cruisin' Through the Cozies Challenge in 2020.  I have done the challenge in the past though and plan on rejoining it again at the 1st level- snoop-which requires me to read 10 books during the 2021 calendar year.  The challenge is hosted by the Socrates Book Reviews blog. 

There are two choices that participants can choose from.  You can either:

1).  Read any cozies of your choice; or

2).  Read 1 book from each of the following cozy sub-genres:

       culinary

       animal related

       craft related

       paranormal

       career based

       holiday themed

       travel

       historical

       one of your choice ( a freebie)

I have selected the second option.  I am already a follower of authors who write culinary, animal themed, craft related, career based, and historical cozies so I think I can get through this challenge.