The Pot Thief Who Studied Ptolemy

This is my third book in the Pot Thief series. In this installment of the series, main character Hubie Schuze is planning another pot heist while sipping margaritas with his best friend Susannah. Hubie does not consider himself a thief because he only takes ancient pots from public lands. However, after Congress passed the Archeological Resources Protection Act his digging for treasures became illegal. Hubie also makes reproductions from original pots. He does not consider them to be fakes, though. 

The publisher's summary:

The pot thief is back, but this time Hubert Schuze' larceny is for a good cause. He wants to recover sacred pots stolen from San Roque, the mysterious New Mexico pueblo closed to outsiders. An easy task for Hubert Schuze, pot digger. Except these pots are not under the ground - they're 150 feet above it. In the top-floor apartment of Rio Grande Lofts, a high-security building which just happens to be one story above Susannah's latest love interest. Hubie's legendary deductive skills lead to a perfect plan which is thwarted when he encounters the beautiful Stella. And when he is arrested for murder. Well, he was in the room where the body was found, everyone heard the shot, and he came out with blood on his hands. Follow Hubie as he stays one step ahead of building security, one step behind Stella, and one step away from a long fall down a garbage chute.

Hubie's shop is located in a dilapidated old building in Albuquerque's Old Town neighborhood. Professor Walter Masoir visited Hubie and stated that he believed retired professor Ognan Gerstner kept a set of pots from the Ma people that were supposed to be sent back to the San Roque Pueblo. Hubie decided to try to recover those pots and return them to their rightful owner.  While reading about Ptolemy's idea that using circles around circles can create a path, he comes up with a plan to break into the building Gerstner lived in in order to steal the pots. It would have been nice for the author to explain how Hubie made this connection. However, while Hubie is attending a party in the building Ognan Gerstner is murdered. Unfortunately the murder didn't occur until midway into the story.  That is way too long for a murder mystery. Most of the dialogue beforehand was humorous musings between Hubie and his friends.

There wasn't much of an investigation into the murder. Hubie gathered his friends and his suspects for a meeting wherein he  posits the name of the killer. The author never tells us how Hubie arrives at his conclusions. 

With many unknowns in the plot, the story falls short on several levels. The book is mainly one humorous dialogue after another from the eccentric main character. He's an interesting character so I hate to rate the book only 2 out of 3 stars. It is what it is.

The Secret Keeper

The Secret Keeper is a historical fiction novel of 1937 India and England. It was published last year on August 12, 2024. The story has a dual timeline from the character Rani in the 1930s and 1940s India to Esme in the current time period.

The publisher's summary:

1938, Rani - the bright and spirited daughter of an Indian Crown Prince - leads a privileged if lonely life. But everything is about to change. Longing for freedom and purpose, she escapes the confines of her father’s palace and meets Prasad – a poor young man – with whom she falls deeply in love. But her plan to gain her father’s approval for the match disastrously backfires.

Estranged from her family and haunted by guilt, Rani’s path takes her from Cambridge to Bletchley Park and a new world of intrigue and secrets. Against the backdrop of war, Rani finds comfort and a sense of belonging with fellow codebreaker William and his young son. Could they heal her heart and become the family she craves?

Then Prasad reappears – and past and present collide, shattering Rani’s fragile happiness. As retribution for the hurt she caused him, he demands she pass him secrets from Bletchley. But at what cost? Torn between her past and her present, love and loyalty, Rani must face up to a heart-wrenching sacrifice . . .

I knew this book would be entertaining because Renita D'Silva always crafts a fine story. The Secret Keeper is another beautiful example of her writing. The novel's setting in India was described must better than that in Britain and Germany. The exotic foods, clothing, and atmosphere brought it to life for me and I can never get enough of reading about India. As such, I loved Rani’s life there. However, most of the story takes place in Bletchley Park. This is where Rani shined as a person. She was able to break through the constraints imposed upon her gender and perform work equal to any man. Her actual workplace was the only setting portrayed in Britain.

In the beginning of the story I had a difficult time connecting the lives of Esme and Rani. The Esme timeline was written with short paragraphs here and there compared to Rani’s. This suited me fine because Rani’s path was the more compelling. The connection between these two ladies was gradually revealed, keeping me hooked. 

Rani’s conundrum was that as a young girl she had lived a life free of the usual constraints against women. Her father was a prince of India and had left his royal life behind him. He supported Rani’s desire to be educated and encouraged her to think critically. However, after his father died he was called back to India where he became the opposite of who he had been. Rani and her mother were forced to live in separate quarters from the men and only saw her father and brother whenever they decided to visit. All of her father’s ideas of equal education for women disappeared. Rani wanted to attend college in Cambridge but was constantly rebuffed. After Rani met Prassad, she stole her father’s sword and gave it to him. The result for her was banishment from India but Prassad was tortured. Rani got what she wanted, though, a Cambridge education.

While Rani appears to be a strong woman, she seems to be a weak woman in her decision-making. I feel that she made some bad decisions while in England. I don't want to give any spoilers here, but many times she acted like the simple woman her newly crowned father believed her to be. I was struck by this dichotomy as I was reading. Rani is a complex character.

The Secret Keeper is a heartwarming tale about cultural differences in gender between the west and east. I loved it and am rating it 5 out of 5 stars.