Silent Witness

Silent Witness is the third book in the Amish Book Club Mystery series. This cozy mystery was published this past Spring on May 26, 2026 and features Rosie Weaver as the amateur sleuth. Rosie is just one of several strong women in the series. She will solve crimes while remaining faithful to her church, which doesn't always like her poking her nose into other people's affairs.

The publisher's summary: 

Rosie Weaver has always relied on logic, discipline, and a strong cup of peppermint tea. But when her neighbor’s barn burns down, and a body is discovered inside, something about the scene feels wrong. The fire is ruled an accident, but the victim had more enemies than friends, and Rosie knows someone is hiding the truth.

The only witness? A kindhearted but non-verbal man whom the entire town has overlooked. And Rosie refuses to let his silence bury what he saw.

Pushed by instinct and the latest book club mystery, Rosie and her book club friends start asking questions no one else will. As resistance builds from her neighbors, outsiders, and even the sheriff, Rose realizes this fire may not be the last.

Can Rosie stop what’s smoldering beneath the silence before it ignites something far worse?

There is much to love about clean Amish mysteries. A writer does not need to use profanity or graphic violence to create a compelling story. Tracy Fredrychowski is one such author. Her use of a mystery book club among Amish women is a fun hook for her series. Amish traditionally don't join book clubs or read "Englischer" novels. Another aspect of this series that I like is the large number of strong female characters. Still, the flavor of an Amish story remains.

While Rosie is the main character, she relies on the other members of her book club to come up with evidence that the group then discusses at their meetings. In this installment of the series the ladies are reading Ashes of Magnolia Manor. In Ashes the detective  picked up on small details such as an old handkerchief and a hidden recipe to solve the crime. Rosie, Lovina and Irma decide to look for similar small details. As usual, the ladies solve the crime, not the sheriff.

 

The story opened with a fire that destroyed the Hostetler barn. There had been fires on the Mullet and Gingerich properties. The setting in Sweet Briar is important. More specifically the farms of the Mullet, Hostetler and Gingerich families are connected and well described. It's easy to see how someone can traverse each property. The past of these three, once close families brings us to the crux of the mystery.

I loved this story and highly recommend it to cozy mystery readers and fans of Amish fiction. 5 out of 5 stars.