The Amish Ballerina

The Amish Ballerina is not a traditional Amish novel. Written by the granddaughter of Amish fiction icon Wanda Brunstetter, I expected a story that fit the profile of Amish fiction. After all, Wanda's name is on book cover. The book reads like a traditional fiction story instead.

The publisher's summary:

Eighteen-year-old Arie Kauffman loves to twirl and leap around the barn in her Amish bonnet and dress, practicing ballet moves her English friend taught her. Her parents would be upset to learn that this longtime interest has progressed to her secretly attending ballet classes. Arie even hides her dance skills from her boyfriend, Edwin Chupp, who often invites her to try new things, knowing she has an artistic heart. Her secrecy, however, is causing damage she may not be able to repair. When offered new opportunities to dance, will Arie break from Amish tradition or hold true to the bonds of her faith and family?

I was disappointed with the book. The idea of an Amish ballet dancer is preposterous. Also, neither parent of the main character, Arie, were nurturing. Arie's boyfriend Edwin likewise had interests in taboo Amish activities such as competitive horseriding. He also had parents who were not nurturing in the Amish faith. In traditional Amish fiction at least one parent encourages faith and behaves appropriately. Here, we have parents who just criticize their kids over and over for no good reason.

I usually read an Amish fiction novel in 90 minutes. The Amish Ballerina took me a few days to get through. This is not because the plot was dull. It's because the storyline reads like general fiction. I didn't want to finish reading the book but kept reading because I thought I was missing something. I wasn't. I am sorry to rate the book 2 out of 5 stars.