Under Water

I was lucky to receive from Book Sirens a copy of Rachel Callaghan's Under Water. The book was published earlier this year.  It is a historical mystery novel with a dual timeline. The mystery is revealed so slowly that the book reads more like a historical fiction story. The story alternates between the 1860s and the present day.  

The publisher's summary:

Submerged beneath layers of history lies a long-ago buried secret. 

During the pandemic lockdown, Iris Pearl impulsively relocates her dulling marriage across the country in a bid to revive it. But renovating their Prerevolutionary Pennsylvania homestead gives Iris more than she bargained for when she makes a gruesome discovery, one that hurtles her and Benny’s haunted past to the present. 

Iris is desperately consumed by the desire to know what happened on her property over a century and a half earlier. Her search leads her to Irish immigrant Aoife Sprigett, the wife of Union soldier William. The further she digs into the mystery of Aoife’s fate, the deeper she reaches into her own secret history.

While William serves in the Civil War, Aoife struggles to uphold her vow to maintain their livelihood, their farm, during his absence. Aoife’s only companion is their hired help, Thomas Walker, a freeborn black laborer. Aoife and Thomas develop a warm friendship as they toil side by side in the fields. Together, Aoife and Thomas sow deep seeds that bear deep-rooted consequences, which are now coming to light.

Will unearthing the truth behind Aoife’s tragic past, which so closely parallels Iris’s own, free her and Benny from their marriage’s haunted history, or will revisiting that dark time destroy it?

I thoroughly enjoyed this Civil War era story. It was meticulously researched and I was particularly impressed that the story was about the people left behind by the soldiers, instead of being a typical war story. The author obviously did a ton of research on the era. She brought alive the 1860s rural Pennsylvania landscape for both the black and white characters. Callaghan was truthful about life for those left behind. She wrote into the plot the tensions between the black and white characters and the tensions between the wealthy and the serving classes. Callaghan also portrayed the divisions between characters who supported the Union and those who were ambivalent about the war. It was interesting that she did not give us characters who supported the confederates. I don't know much about the history of the Civil War but on my past readings on the subject there were only two sides, those heavily supporting the Union and those heavily supporting the Confederacy. There was no in-between. Perhaps there really were Southerners living in this era who did not support the Confederacy or who just didn't care and wanted to continue their lives without any interference from a war.

Aoife's story was the most compelling. Her husband William volunteered to fight on behalf of the Union and left her to deal with their farm with only one farmhand to help her.  I had to check Wikipedia to determine how to pronounce her name because I knew this was going to bother me.  It is pronounced "eefah."  Aoife went through many changes during her husband's absence but she probably endured them so well because she was a former servant. She knew how to get things done. The mystery about the baby found on Iris's property was also a big part of the plot.  The reveal was not written like the usual historical mystery. There was no investigation by a law enforcement agency but rather by a professional genealogist. The body that was found in the pond was over 100 years old. I will leave my comments at that in order to not be a spoiler.

Under Water was an engrossing read. Historical fiction fans will love it. I am rating it 5 out of 5 stars.