Book of the Month: October

My best book for this month is Susan Wittig Albert's Hemlock. It is a cozy mystery that normally takes place in Pecan Springs, TX. However, Albert has sent her protagonist to the east coast to assist a librarian friend in locating a missing rare book titled A Curious Herbal. I have found that when a series author changes the setting, that the book is not as good as usual. Here we have a great example of how to change setting and still have an interesting novel. I was also impressed with the addition of an alternating plot in Hemlock. Again, Albert has not done this before but she wrote a fascinating tale about a fifteenth century women, Elizabeth Blackwell, who wrote a book containing drawings of over 500 herbs and plants that apothecaries used to treat people. The book had vanished from its locked display case in the library of Hemlock House in the North Caroline mountains. I thought that the fifteenth century plot was more interesting than the current era story. Hemlock is a cozy, art theft mystery and historical fiction all rolled in to one novel. It was superb!

A Tapestry of Light

I have always loved India fiction. A Tapestry of Light is another great addition to this genre.  Most of the books in this genre that I have seen concern the historical periods of the British Raj and Partition.  Some of them are stories about modern women.  It would be nice to read a novel about the mughal period and I wonder whether any writer has written about this time period.

Back to the book. A Tapestry of Light begins in Calcutta in 1866. Ottilie Russell has a British father and an Indian mother and does not belong to either society. She, and others like her, were referred to as Eurasian. After Ottilie's mother Maji dies, she begins to take work embroidering gowns for the elite with beetle wing embroidery in order to support her younger brother Thaddeus and her grandmother Nani. This type of embroidery was passed down to her from generations of Indian women before her.  She was an expert at it and was able to make a living from it. A few months later a stranger named Everett Scott walked into her home to advise the family that Thaddeus had inherited the Baroncy of Sunderland in England.  Scott traveled to India in order to take Thaddeus to England. Ottilie refuses to allow Thaddeus to leave and is aghast that she is learning for the first time about her father's family. Eventually Ottilie agrees to let Thaddeus travel to England but only if she is allowed to go with him. However, life is not easy for any of them in England because Thaddeus appears to be white, Ottilie looks like an Indian.

I LOVED this novel! I particularly liked the India setting. It has warm weather, great food and   colorful clothing. I could picture in my mind the saris that Ottilie wore. I am a fan of them. England, however, is cold and grey just like the city I live in so it is not appealing to me. The characters were interesting, even the secondary characters. Ottilie is a great protagonist.  As a half-breed, she has conflicted views about her ancestry but feels more Indian than English.  Her mother taught her to be proud of her Indian ancestry and encouraged the Christian faith to which both of her parents subscribed. Ottilie's mother Maji was a main character early in the novel but after she died, Maji's mother Nani became more prominent. Ottilie remembers the advice she received from both of them as she went through life dealing with her loves, neighbors and business associates.  Everett Scott was an interesting character too. He does not have a pristine ancestry either but he is willing to talk about it honestly. I have never read about a character in his position who didn't try to hide the unsavory bits of their family history. Usually, at least in India fiction, they try to be just like the elites of society, hoping to fit in.

This was the first book written by Kimberly Duffy that I have read.  I am impressed and look forward to reading her earlier novels.  5 out of 5 stars.

The Beginning

It has always amazed me how Beverly Lewis can continue to come up with great stories to tell.  41 adult fiction novels has not slowed down her imagination. The Beginning is another one that is especially poignant. While her readers will expect a romance story that always ends well, the reason for the title has nothing to do with courting and marriage. I won't be a spoiler. You will want to read the book to find out.

The story begins with Susie Mast wondering if she will ever have any boy interested enough in her to want to marry her. She hopes that Obie Yoder has romantic feelings for her but she never expresses her feelings to him.  Suffering from the death of her brother several years earlier, Susie has found that the best way to cope is to keep busy. She is always cleaning, working in her mother's store or selling her family tree embroideries. She rarely relaxes or socializes. Susie's mother, Aquilla, has been in declining health since the death of her husband and son in an auto accident. Her adopted sister, Britta, is a big help to her with chores but has begun to ask alot of questions about her birth parents. Susie knows a little about Britta's past but is afraid to tell her anything about her adoption.  She fears more loss will occur if Britta gets the answers she is seeking.  

The Beginning is one of my favorite books that Lewis has written. The ending gathers and clarifies all the loose ends written in to the story.  While I haven't read all of her books, this type of ending seemed more complex than the ones that I have previously read.  It made the book much more satisfying than the usual girl finally gets the boy.  The wisdom issued from the lips of the elderly women in this Amish district was amazing and the foods the ladies prepared made me hungry.  I ended up ordering in on the day that I read the book.  If there is anything unusual about the story  it was how often they made tea. Someone was making tea on almost every page. The characters must have spent alot of time in the outhouse.

Beverly Lewis is the reason that I read Amish fiction.  She is the gold standard for these types of stories and I highly recommend this novel.  5 out of 5 stars.

Home

I have just read Home #1 through #5 and it is fantastic. It is the story of a mother and son who leave Guatemala on foot and enter the U. S. illegally. Mercedes Gomez and eight year old Juan do not speak English and are surprised to find out the there is a new American president who has closed the border. When they left Guatemala two weeks prior, Obama was still the president. President Trump immediately changed the rules concerning immigration when he took office but Mercedes did not know about the rule changes. Throughout their first 2 weeks in America they were held in "the cage" as it was called. Later Juan was taken away and held with other kids. Shortly thereafter he was bussed to another location. Mercedes did not know where her son was taken and offered to return to Guatemala if she could get Juan back. However, she was told that it was too late. 

While this story was sad, it has its positive moments. Soon after arriving in the US, Juan discovers that he has supernatural powers. While living with an aunt he begins to learn how to control his power. When Juan finds out that his mother will be deported, his powers get out of control again and bring devastation to . . . I'm not going to tell you. If you haven't read this comic series yet, you need to get it ASAP. It is a great story.

Covid Chronicles

Covid Chronicles is an anthology of short comic strips by 65 cartoonists about the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic. It is serious material and sometimes seemed to be too dark for my taste. However, it is important to have this snapshot of life in this pandemic for future generations. We read about working from home frivolity, teaching kids at home, relatives dying, empty grocery shelves and lots of drawings of people dead in their beds. The only other comic anthology that I can remember being similar to Covid Chronicles is A Fire Story edited by Brian Fies. It was also hard to read. A Fire Story was an anthology of comic strips about the Northern California wildfires in 2017. Both books are filled with overwhelming negative emotions that the reader needs to take a breather while reading them.

Stacking the Shelves #9

I am on vacation for the rest of October and wanted to pick up more historical novels by Edward Rutherford. His China was fabulous. Sadly, I could only find one of them at my local bookstore.  London is a wonderful 1,126 pages long and I am happy that I was able to get it.  The book is an epic saga of the city of London that spans 2,000 years, from the era of Julius Caesar to the 20th century. Many generations of six families are showcased here.

I also went to my public library and found several books that I have been waiting all year to be published.  Laura Childs' Twisted Tea Christmas is the latest installment of her Indigo Teashop Mysteries. S. D. Sykes' 5th book in her medieval mystery series is titled The Good Death.  The Widow Queen by Elzbieta Cherezinska gives us a historical look at Polish Queen Swietoslawa. It will be refreshing to read a historical novel that doesn't take place in the big three: England, France and Italy.  

Which one to start with?  The chunkster London.

One Night in Tehran

One Night in Tehran is the first book in Luana Ehrlich's Titus Ray spy thriller series. It was published i 2014 and now consists of 8 novels.  What makes this book different is that the main character is a new Christian.  While he tries to live the Christian lifestyle, the book has a spy thriller feel not a Christian fiction feel. 

The publisher's summary:

"Veteran CIA officer Titus Ray - on the run from the Iranian secret police - finds shelter with a group of Iranian Christians in Tehran. While urging him to become a believer in Jesus Christ, they manage to smuggle Titus out of Iran to freedom in Turkey.  Returning to the States, he discovers his Iranian mission failed because of political infighting within the Agency.  After Titus delivers a scathing indictment against the deputy director of operations, he's forced to take a year's medical leave in Oklahoma.  Before leaving Langley, Titus learns he's been targeted by a Hezbollah assassin hired by the Iranians.  Now, while trying to figure out what it means to be a follower of Christ, he must decide if the Iranian couple he meets in Norman, Oklahoma has ties to the man who's trying to kill him, and if Nikki Saxon can be trusted with his secrets.  Can a man trained to lie and deceive live a life of faith?  Should he trust the beautiful young detective with his secrets?  Was the bullet that killed his friend meant for him?"

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. There is a lot of suspense in each chapter that keeps you reading until you finish it and it certainly is a timely story.  I was expecting to see more domestic terrorism involved in the plot since it takes place in Oklahoma where the first act of domestic terrorism occurred in America. There is no link to that event though. Another aspect of the book that is different from most spy thrillers is that there is no sex or foul language. This is a clean, character driven story with awesome characters. Besides Titus, a former spook friend, Danny Jarrar, was able to leave the Agency and find a way to live the Christian life in Norman, Oklahoma. Also, the Oklahoma setting was interesting because there were so many Middle Eastern countries with operatives in the state.  I wonder whether this is true or was created by the author to bolster the spy story.  The part of the story that took place in Tehran was authentic too. 

While the main character is a Christian, this novel still reads like a daring spy thriller.  I highly recommend it to mystery fans.  5 out of 5 stars.

Parenthesis

Parenthesis is Elodie Durand's debut graphic novel. It is a memoir of five years of her life suffering from tumor induced epilepsy. The author changes her name, calling herself Judith, but it is her story and she wrote it ten years after it occurred. After finishing all her classes for a master's degree, Elodie only had her thesis to write. She began having momentary spells that continued to be spells of several minutes. Soon she was having multiple seizures daily that increased in length as well as period of recovery. She moved back in with her parents who eventually even had to dress her. Elodie had severe memory loss that lasted weeks. Her neurologist recommended her for gamma knife brain surgery which she underwent a few months later. However, she continued to get worse. There is a recovery but in my mind getting there was worse than the descent into darkness. Elodie had to deal with cerebral edema that comes with this type of surgery. 

The author does a great job of describing what life was like when she was barely conscious. I felt as though as I was there with her, something that I have not felt when reading stories of those who are dealing with cancer or paralysis. Her drawings also show the darkness of her memories from when she was barely awake. It is interesting that there was an awareness of something going on but she couldn't put her finger on what is was.  Elodie's story is moving, scary and gripping all at the same time. The choice of a title for the book is perfect: her normal life was interrupted by the opening of a parenthesis that she was not sure would ever close.  

5 out of 5 stars.

The Stationery Shop

The Stationery Shop is a sweet story that takes place in Tehran, California and Boston. The Khanom sisters, Roya and Zari, are coming of age in Tehran. They are quite different in their outlook on life. Roya is the heroine of the book and her story concentrates on the lost love of her first boyfriend, Bahman Aslan. 

Roya is a dreamy, idealistic seventeen-year-old living in 1953 Tehran. There is plenty of political upheaval as the Shah and the National Front fight for supremacy. Roya is not interested in politics and finds a literary oasis in the neighborhood stationery shop owned by Mr. Fakhri. There she finds pens, paper and Persian poetry books and she visits the shop every Tuesday afternoon when school is over. One day a cute boy comes in and is given a stack of papers to deliver by Mr. Fakhri.  Bahman Aslan catches Roya's heart even before they are introduced. Their romance blossoms under the watchful eye of Mr. Fakhri. A few months later, on the eve of their marriage, Roya agrees to meet Bahman at the town square where violence erupts as a result of a coup d'erat that gives the Shah all of the power. In the packed crowd Roya does not see Bahman. She tries for several weeks to contact him but is not successful. In her grief Roya moves to California with her sister to attend college. There she meets Walter Archer. Roya and Walter marry and move to Boston so that Walter can attend law school. They live there and build a family. Sixty years after moving to America, Roya finds Bahman in a nursing home nearby her home where both of them meet and learn what ultimately happened earlier in their lives.

I love Middle Eastern novels.  Most of their traditions, and especially food, charm me. I loved reading how Mrs. Khanom prepared the Iranian traditional foods. It makes me want to visit an Iranian restaurant near my home and I probably will go there on the weekend. The closeness of the families in the novel is also heartwarming. It's too bad that this part of their culture did not transplant well in the U. S.

I felt sorry for Walter.  His wife could not show herself fully to him no matter how long they were married. He accepted her as she is. I also felt sorry for Roya because she could not get over her first love. We all have a first love that lives in our memory but most of us can move on.  I didn't understand why Roya couldn't. There must be something about her personality that prevents her from feeling fully. Zari is a secondary character and we see her as the complete opposite of her sister.  Zari has the ability to quickly recover from any downturns in her life. She sees people clearly but she is not bothered by them. 

The three settings, Tehran, California and Boston, did not seem all that important to the story. The only thing about the Tehran setting that moved me was the descriptions of the food and how they were made. I think, though, that family could be a setting here. It's the family binds that make this story touching. 

I loved this novel and am rating it 5 out of 5 stars.  It is recommended highly, primarily to women.

The End of October

The End of October is a medical thriller about a devastating virus that begins in Asia and soon thereafter goes global. This riveting story begins at in internment camp in Indonesia where forty seven people die from acute hemorrhagic fever. When microbiologist Henry Parsons travels there on behalf of the World Health Organization he suddenly learns that his driver is infected and is on his way to join millions of worshippers in the annual Hajj to Mecca. Henry joins with a Saudi prince and doctor in an attempt to quarantine all of the pilgrims in the holy city.  It doesn't work.  The deputy director of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security is a Russian immigrant who scrambles to mount a response to what she thinks may be an act of biowar. Some people believe that the virus was bioengineered by Putin because there are few cases of it in Russia. The Russian leader, of course, blames the Americans. As the disease travels throughout the U. S. it decimates the population and religious, scientific and governmental institutions are dismantled. 

Obviously, this  novel is timely.  It was published in April 2020 so I doubt that the author had any idea that we would be dealing with a pandemic when he wrote the story. It is interesting to note that the president in the novel wears orange pancake makeup and the vice president will not make any decisions without praying first. To add to this phenomenon the main character worries about the danger his family could face while camping in off grid sites in Grand Teton National Park.

The sense of emergency contributed to the fast pace.  The reader does not know what the virus is or how fast it will kill people. Henry goes through a mental checklist to help him identify the origin of the virus and when it was revealed in the last 3 pages, I was astonished. I was not expecting this ending. Given all of my newfound knowledge on pandemics, I knew where the plot was heading. It was still a fantastic read. 4 out of 5 stars.

The Bone Code

I don't read many Kathy Reichs novels. She writes forensic mysteries which I never could get interested in.  This particular novel concerns using family DNA companies to identify dead people. I have read several forensic DNA novels lately and find that I like them so I selected The Bone Code as my entry for October's Monthly Key Word Reading Challenge. It was published in July 2021.

Temperance Brennan is the main character in the series.  When she examined two decomposing female bodies that were inside a medical waste container off the Charleston, SC coast, she recognized many of the details that were identical to an unsolved case that she handled in Quebec fifteen years earlier.  The story began well but soon devolved into corny idioms and dialogue between Tempe and her husband. Pages 100 -200 were dull.  No action happened. The story did pick up for the remaining 150 pages but I could not overcome the boredom of the first half of the book. There was no suspense whatsoever and clues sprung up quickly and were then discarded.  

I cannot imagine anyone under 60 who would be able to stand the dialogue in the book.  There were so many corny phrases from the 1970s (ask me how I know!) that would stop them reading. "Hot damn, holy freaking shit, over my patootie, a real pisser" plus boring paragraphs "I went inside, brushed my teeth and changed into jeans" or "I was finishing a one-line report..." Common French words were part of the dialogue on every page but I did not see any reason for them. 

Now I remember why I don't read Kathy Reichs novels. Perhaps I am spoiled by reading Nathan Dylan Goodwin's Forensic Genealogist Series. Goodwin adds plenty of suspense to his stories and they focus solely on solving the puzzle. 

I would skip The Bone Code. 2 out of 5 stars.

The Stolen Lady

The Stolen Lady is the latest novel in Laura Morelli's art mysteries. All of them are standalone books. In this particular novel there are alternating plots that take place during the 1400s and during WWII. The fictional characters are based somewhat on real people and the backstory on how the Louvre staff moved its works of art is well researched. Below is the publisher's summary:

France, 1939

At the dawn of World War II, Anne Guichard, a young archivist employed at the Louvre, arrives home to find her brother missing. While she works to discover his whereabouts, refugees begin flooding into Paris and German artillery fire rattles the city. Once they reach the city, the Nazis will stop at nothing to get their hands on the Louvre's art collection. Anne is quickly sent to the Castle of Chambord, where the Louvre's most precious artworks - including the Mona Lisa - are being transferred to ensure their safety. With the Germans hard on their heels, Anne frantically moves the Mona Lisa and other treasures again and again in an elaborate game of hide and seek. As the threat to the masterpieces and her life grows closer, Anne also begins to lean the truth about her brother and the role he plays in this dangerous game.

Florence, 1479

House servant Bellina Sardi's future seems fixed when she accompanies her newly married mistress, Lisa Gherardini, to her home across the Arno. Lisa's husband, a prosperous silk merchant, is aligned with the powerful Medici, his home filled with luxuries and treasures. But soon, Bellina finds herself bewitched by a charismatic one who has urged Florentines to rise up against the Medici and to empty their homes of the riches and jewels her new employer prizes. When Master Leonardo da Vinci is commissioned to paint a portrait of Lisa, Bellina finds herself tasked with hiding an impossible secret. 

To say that I loved this story is an understatement. The richness of Florence and Milan set a striking contrast to the French countryside where the Louvre employees lived a spartan existence under Nazi rule. In my mind you cannot find a more beautiful setting than Florence. I love the art, cathedrals, fabrics and food. The pleasures that the ruling class were lucky to have engaged in will always seduce my imagination. If only to be rich in Florence during the Middle Ages. 

One of the secondary characters, Lucie, is based on a real woman who, as a Louvre employee, documented the movement of the artworks from Paris to the countryside. Through her efforts we know what happened during this time period. Our protagonist Anne worked under Lucie at the Louvre but they were equals during the run from the Nazis. The author drew upon Lucie's documentation to write this part of the story. While I can't get enough of the Italian Renaissance period I believe that Anne's story is the most compelling. 

The author gives us an interesting viewpoint into how Da Vinci felt about his Mona Lisa. We see him as he begins the portrait and decades later before his death. Morelli shows him initially believing that a portrait will never bring him accolades. However, he never truly believes that the painting is finished and works on it periodically while he looks for other commissions that will bring him fame. He too is captivated by the smile that he remembers the real Lisa had and endeavors to recreate it in this portrait. 

The Stolen Lady is a must read for historical fiction fans. 5 out of 5 stars.

Hemlock

Hemlock's action takes place far away from its usual Pecan Springs, Texas location. For most authors this results in a poorly written novel. In fact, Susan Wittig Albert did this once before and the book was awful. In Hemlock, though, she has masterfully written a story that is engaging from the first page until the last.

Our main character China Bayles receives a phone call from a friend in North Carolina. She is asked by Dorothea Harper, director of the Hemlock House Foundation, to visit her to help her with locating a missing, rare book titled A Curious Herbal. The book was written by Elizabeth Blackwell in the fifteenth century and contains her drawings of 500 herbs and plants that apothecaries used to treat people. The book vanished from its locked display case in Hemlock House, an old mansion in the North Carolina mountains. 

Another prominent character is Jenna Peterson, a graduate student who is interning at Hemlock House and is assisting Dorothea with cataloging the thousands of books in the library. Both Jenna and Dorothea live in the mansion. The police believe that one of them stole the book, mainly because they are the only people with access to the library. It's value is in the hundreds of thousands and would make either one of them wealthy. Additional characters include Police Chief Curtis, bookseller Jed Conway,  and Elizabeth Blackwell herself.  Elizabeth's story is told via drafts of a historical novel that Jenna is writing and sends to China for input. Elizabeth's story is a big part of Hemlock and is the most interesting part of the novel. There are several minor characters who are not mentioned often but are integral to solving the mystery.  These include relatives, the housekeeper and members of the Hemlock House board of directors.

Hemlock is not a cozy murder mystery but rather a cozy art theft mystery. All of the prior books in the series involved the solving of a murder. This installment of the series is fantastic. There is even a little suspense. When China walks up the rickety stairs of the mansion it is implied that she is avoiding danger of some sort not related to the steps.  This is a red herring. There are quite a few of these types of hints in the book and you don't know what will be important until the end of the story.

Hemlock is one of the author's best novels. 5 out of 5 stars.

Peril

I knew that Bob Woodward's Peril would be a great read even though there have already been several excerpts in the media. It was. I had two profound thoughts after finishing the book but let me first state that the time period covered was the last six months of Trump's presidency and the first six months of Biden's presidency.

What struck me the most was how long the military had been controlling Trump's ability to begin a war. Military officers got together before scheduled meetings in the Oval Office to decide beforehand who would say what in the meetings. One person would be selected to take the heat from Trump, i.e., tell him the truth. Telling Trump the truth always resulted in him screaming obscenities at them. This was true from Trump's initial days in Office until he left Office. When the 2020 election was nearing, military officials were even more hands on because Trump was saying privately that he wanted military action against several other nations. It has been reported in the news that the Chinese were worried that the U.S. would attack them. This worry was true for the entire 2020 calendar year not just near the election date. In fact, the Chinese military was on high alert for an attack all year as were the Russians and Iranians. The American military had several discussions with the Chinese to advise that the U S. would not attack them and in so many words say they were in control of the nuclear weapons, not Trump. 

With such extraordinary efforts being made to avert wars why did no one remove Trump from Office? The military took some measures that were illegal. While I am glad they did so the fact remains that their actions were illegal. My latest reading of the U.S. Constitution shows that the vice president is the only person who can call a cabinet meeting to invoke the 25th Amendment and remove Trump.  In my mind Pence is just as guilty of illegal acts by failing to do his job. I guess the military did what they could given that Pence refused to do his duty. Former Joint Chief's Chairman General Milley was quoted in the book as saying that the military only has an obligation to the Constitution, not the Commander in Chief.  He upheld his duty to the Constitution by preventing Trump from starting a war, one that would also be illegal under the Constitution. We have former Vice President Pence to thank for the mess. I was not aware how much he contributed to it before reading the book. The only reason that this mess occurred is because he failed to uphold his own constitutional duties. Note, though, that the authors did not discuss Pence. These are my thoughts.

The book begins with Biden's inaugural address where he mentions that we are in a winter of peril. The book ends with the author's statement "peril remains." I agree with their assessment but most of the time I push that thought from my mind. It's just too upsetting. Peril should be required reading. I am rating it 5 out of 5 stars.